Rubric

Find Rubric
Keep in mind that 30 students have already been assessed using this rubric. Changing it will affect their evaluations.
CTA 1B
CTA 1B
Criteria Ratings Pts
Empirical - Participant Recruitment
A description of the participant recruitment strategy is provided along with the backgrounds of the individual participants.
threshold: pts
5 pts
Impressive Work
4 pts
Good Work
3 pts
Flawed Work
2 pts
Seriously Flawed Work
1 pts
Present
0 pts
Missing
pts
5 pts
--
Empirical - Participant 1 Strategy
A table analyzing the strategy use and solutions generated by participant 1 is included as described in the write up.
threshold: pts
5 pts
Impressive Work
4 pts
Good Work
3 pts
Flawed Work
2 pts
Seriously Flawed Work
1 pts
Present
0 pts
Missing
pts
5 pts
--
Empirical - Participant 1 Diagram
A flow chart or concept map of the strategy used by participant 1 is provided that thoroughly covers the problem solving task.
threshold: pts
5 pts
Impressive Work
4 pts
Good Work
3 pts
Flawed Work
2 pts
Seriously Flawed Work
1 pts
Present
0 pts
Missing
pts
5 pts
--
Empirical - Participant 2 Strategy
A table analyzing the strategy use and solutions generated by participant 2 is included as described in the write up.
threshold: pts
5 pts
Impressive Work
4 pts
Good Work
3 pts
Flawed Work
2 pts
Seriously Flawed Work
1 pts
Present
0 pts
Missing
pts
5 pts
--
Empirical - Participant 2 Diagram
A flow chart or concept map of the strategy used by participant 1 is provided that thoroughly covers the problem solving task.
threshold: pts
5 pts
Impressive Work
4 pts
Good Work
3 pts
Flawed Work
2 pts
Seriously Flawed Work
1 pts
Present
0 pts
Missing
pts
5 pts
--
Empirical - Synthesis
A synthesis of a common novice approach is provided included what difficulties novices actually encountered.
threshold: pts
5 pts
Impressive Work
4 pts
Good Work
3 pts
Flawed Work
2 pts
Seriously Flawed Work
1 pts
Present
0 pts
Missing
pts
5 pts
--
Empirical - Diagram
A flow chart or concept map that integrating the common novice approach(es) is provided covering how novices approach the task.
threshold: pts
5 pts
Impressive Work
4 pts
Good Work
3 pts
Flawed Work
2 pts
Seriously Flawed Work
1 pts
Present
0 pts
Missing
pts
5 pts
--
Reflection - Theoretical vs Empirical
A brief discussion of the differences between the predictions made in theoretical task analysis and the results of the empirical task analysis is provided.
threshold: pts
10 to >8.0 pts
Impressive Work
8 to >6.0 pts
Good Work
6 to >4.0 pts
Flawed Work
4 to >2.0 pts
Seriously Flawed Work
2 to >0.0 pts
Present
0 pts
Missing
pts
10 pts
--
Implications for Game Design
A brief discussion of implications for a potential game design is provided that reflects on the results of the CTA.
threshold: pts
5 pts
Impressive Work
4 pts
Good Work
3 pts
Flawed Work
2 pts
Seriously Flawed Work
1 pts
Present
0 pts
Missing
pts
5 pts
--
Total Points: 50 out of 50