Rubric

Find Rubric
Keep in mind that 27 students have already been assessed using this rubric. Changing it will affect their evaluations.
Critique Rubric S22
Critique Rubric S22
Criteria Ratings Pts
Game Metadata
Post provides metadata about the game including: title, developer / designer, platform, high-level subject area, and link to the game.
threshold: pts
3 pts
All metadata present
2 pts
Something missing
0 pts
No Metadata
pts
3 pts
--
Learning Objectives
Post discusses the learning objectives of the game including any assumed prior knowledge or potential opportunities to transfer.
threshold: pts
5 pts
Impressive Work
4 pts
Good Work
3 pts
OK Work
2 pts
Flawed Work
1 pts
Not Missing
0 pts
Missing
pts
5 pts
--
Game Elements
Post discusses the design of the game itself, including the core gameplay loop, important mechanics or systems, and the player experience.
threshold: pts
5 pts
Impressive Work
4 pts
Good Work
3 pts
OK Work
2 pts
Flawed Work
1 pts
Not Missing
0 pts
Missing
pts
5 pts
--
Learning Mechanisms
Post discusses the learning mechanism the game engages including how the mechanism relates to the learning objectives and relevant learning science principles that are implemented notably well or notably poorly.
threshold: pts
5 pts
Impressive Work
4 pts
Good Work
3 pts
OK Work
2 pts
Flawed Work
1 pts
Not Missing
0 pts
Missing
pts
5 pts
--
Overall Critique
Post presents a reasoned critique of the game and makes a statement about why the game works well or doesn't.
threshold: pts
5 pts
Impressive Work
4 pts
Good Work
3 pts
OK Work
2 pts
Flawed Work
1 pts
Not Missing
0 pts
Missing
pts
5 pts
--
Total Points: 23 out of 23